Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

School Spycam Drama
#1

So some school is being sued for turning on the webcams on their student issued laptops.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/02/22/...k_spy_row/

Quote:School student Blake Robbins was told last November he had been accused of "improper behavior in his home" - and the evidence for this behaviour was a photograph of him in his bedroom taken via his laptop's camera.

There is so much wrong with this, not the least of which is the school saying the kid behaved 'improperly' at home. He's at home, his behavior there is his parent's problem not the schools. And that's not even addressing the privacy issue.

Thoughts? Do they have a right to do this? It is the school's laptop after all.

I will show you fear in a handful of dust.
Reply
#2

why is he masturbating with a school computer?
Reply
#3

Anhil8tor Wrote:why is he masturbating with a school computer?

Cause the family computer is in the living room?

I will show you fear in a handful of dust.
Reply
#4

They had no right to spy on their students in their homes.

I hope the judge/jury throws the book(mac-book) at them.

Son, I am Disappoint.
Reply
#5

Tribal Dragon Wrote:They had no right to spy on their students in their homes.

I hope the judge/jury throws the book(mac-book) at them.

Agreed. I think they have a right to have spyware on the laptop for log tracking, the same way a company has that right with its computers. If the school doesn't want porn on their laptops fine, but turning on a laptop camera in a teens bedroom with no permission? Why not just take an ad out in the paper: "Lower Merion School District now hiring perverts and pedophiles."

However, I do like the fact that it is Macs being used for evil for once and not PCs.

I will show you fear in a handful of dust.
Reply
#6

If they own the laptops and make the parents sign off on it knowing the school has 100% control of them I'm not sure what you can sue them for.I think its hilarious a kid got caught masturbating on his computer.

See You In Toledo
Reply
#7

Do you sign your rights away when you rent an apartment? Are they free to come in at any time and make sure you aren't treating the place like garbage?

Son, I am Disappoint.
Reply
#8

leucifer Wrote:Agreed. I think they have a right to have spyware on the laptop for log tracking, the same way a company has that right with its computers. If the school doesn't want porn on their laptops fine, but turning on a laptop camera in a teens bedroom with no permission? Why not just take an ad out in the paper: "Lower Merion School District now hiring perverts and pedophiles."

I agree. Checking the computer to see where the student has been is one thing; spying on them with the laptop's camera is way over the line.
Reply
#9

Tribal Dragon Wrote:Do you sign your rights away when you rent an apartment? Are they free to come in at any time and make sure you aren't treating the place like garbage?

They were free laptops.Nobody paid for them but the school.It is their property no matter where it is.Its like arguing over getting fired after your employer finds porn on a computer they issued you.

See You In Toledo
Reply
#10

BIRD33 Wrote:They were free laptops.Nobody paid for them but the school.It is their property no matter where it is.Its like arguing over getting fired after your employer finds porn on a computer they issued you.

Much different buddy. I can look at where an employee has visited, but I can't spy on them at home through their webcam.

Son, I am Disappoint.
Reply
#11

BIRD33 Wrote:They were free laptops.Nobody paid for them but the school.It is their property no matter where it is.Its like arguing over getting fired after your employer finds porn on a computer they issued you.

The fact that they're using cameras should be disclosed before the families take the laptops home.
Reply
#12

BIRD33 Wrote:They were free laptops.Nobody paid for them but the school.It is their property no matter where it is.Its like arguing over getting fired after your employer finds porn on a computer they issued you.

Tracking use is one thing, but think turning on a camera on the laptop in someone's home (and bedroom) especially a teens, opens them up to all sorts of privacy issues. Let's assume there's a kid doing nothing wrong. they use the laptop to write a paper, they plan to finish in the morning, so they leave the laptop open on their desk and get undressed for bed. Now you have a school with the ability to literally spy on kids and not just spy on the laptop usage, they're actually spying on the kid which has nothing to do with laptop usage.

I will show you fear in a handful of dust.
Reply
#13

Let us not forget that while the school district may have paid for them- where does the school district get it's money? Oh yeah, the taxpayers. So whose laptops are they really?


(Sorry. I had to start some shit.)
Reply
#14

bam Wrote:Let us not forget that while the school district may have paid for them- where does the school district get it's money? Oh yeah, the taxpayers. So whose laptops are they really?


(Sorry. I had to start some shit.)
Retarded Tangent

[Image: palin%20biden%20retarded%20vagina.jpg]

Son, I am Disappoint.
Reply
#15

bam Wrote:Let us not forget that while the school district may have paid for them- where does the school district get it's money? Oh yeah, the taxpayers. So whose laptops are they really?


(Sorry. I had to start some shit.)

I believe that was in England. I don't know if their schools & taxes work the same.
Reply
#16

leucifer Wrote:Tracking use is one thing, but think turning on a camera on the laptop in someone's home (and bedroom) especially a teens, opens them up to all sorts of privacy issues. Let's assume there's a kid doing nothing wrong. they use the laptop to write a paper, they plan to finish in the morning, so they leave the laptop open on their desk and get undressed for bed. Now you have a school with the ability to literally spy on kids and not just spy on the laptop usage, they're actually spying on the kid which has nothing to do with laptop usage.

The parents signed off on the school having 100% access to them.If the parents didnt know what that meant shame on them for signing the paper.Do I see whats wrong here from the parents and kids perspective?Yea.Should they be able to spy on the kids in their bedrooms?no.Should the kids be taking their clothes off in front of a school issued lap top?No.Here's an idea.Know what you are signing and don't jerk off on a school computer.

See You In Toledo
Reply
#17

BIRD33 Wrote:The parents signed off on the school having 100% access to them.If the parents didnt know what that meant shame on them for signing the paper.Do I see whats wrong here from the parents and kids perspective?Yea.Should they be able to spy on the kids in their bedrooms?no.Should the kids be taking their clothes off in front of a school issued lap top?No.Here's an idea.Know what you are signing and don't jerk off on a school computer.

For once Bird, I agree with you.
Reply
#18

And no pics for TD.
Reply
#19

BIRD33 Wrote:The parents signed off on the school having 100% access to them.If the parents didnt know what that meant shame on them for signing the paper.Do I see whats wrong here from the parents and kids perspective?Yea.Should they be able to spy on the kids in their bedrooms?no.Should the kids be taking their clothes off in front of a school issued lap top?No.Here's an idea.Know what you are signing and don't jerk off on a school computer.

[Image: Pedo_Bear_Seal.png]

Son, I am Disappoint.
Reply
#20

bam Wrote:Let us not forget that while the school district may have paid for them- where does the school district get it's money? Oh yeah, the taxpayers. So whose laptops are they really?


(Sorry. I had to start some shit.)

By that logic every Pennsylvanian should be able to access every state computer.Your tax, medical and personal finance records out there for everyone to see.Not really practical, Mrs Glenn Beck.

See You In Toledo
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
Last Post by Reaper
04-20-2010, 08:39 PM
Last Post by BIRD33
07-12-2009, 08:10 PM
Last Post by BIRD33
01-22-2009, 05:48 PM
Last Post by Ntype
11-15-2008, 01:14 PM
Last Post by BIRD33
03-20-2008, 10:31 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)