Posts: 32,452
Threads: 5
Joined: Jun 2004
Reputation:
0
Flumper could a human baby learn whats right and what is wrong without some form of religious guidance?
I don't think people were evil before religion came along.
See You In Toledo
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
One theory of morality suggests that it's linked with cognitive development.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kohlberg%27...evelopment
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
Flumper Barflusterbutt Wrote:well, i think that they could definitely develop some ideas of what they think are acceptable in order for a group to get along without too many problems. But I think it would depend on the child and his or her natural tendancies. I do believe that some kids are born more aggressive and prone to bad behavior. Even a mental disorder untreated could cause a child to do things that might otherwise seem to be unacceptable.
This is true regardless of religion.
Flumper Wrote:So, I guess my answer would be that I do believe that some type of accepted rules of interaction and behavior would develop, but I would not say that they would mirror the same things that religion teaches. At least not in the early stages.
Charles Manson made the rules for his "family" to live by. That worked out well.
We can't generalize from one example. Surely, you can admit there are countless examples are very religious people who do evil things?
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
Flumper Barflusterbutt Wrote:Probably best to keep it simply on the concept of what is moral and what is immoral.
I believe, that by definition, religion has to be involved to distinguish between the two. Otherwise, what can you use to label something one or the other?
Option #1 -
Cucumber Wrote:One theory of morality suggests that it's linked with cognitive development.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kohlberg%27...evelopment
Option #2 - Intrinsic motivation
Option #3 - I think you are talking more about Divine Law?
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
Posts: 5,926
Threads: 212
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation:
0
There's nothing I like better than a good pray.
cLaY Wrote:Knick-Knack Paddy's Whack, suckin' TF's Bone...
BIRD33 Wrote:You know who would be hilarious in a thread with this type of situation going on?Paddy.
BIRD33 Wrote:I was battling with the mods just like everyone else.
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
Flumper, because the thread is about religion, and you seem to be asserting that our moral conscious perhaps comes from religious beliefs and teachings, can I conclude that you think the bible should be used as a moral handbook?
ETA: :eek: in case the answer is yes.
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
Posts: 32,452
Threads: 5
Joined: Jun 2004
Reputation:
0
Fair enough.Its a chicken or the egg debate at this point.I choose to believe since we created religion we also without religious influences created morals.
See You In Toledo
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
I think many Christians are taught a warped version of morality. This warped version starts with the false premise that God is moral and anything God does in then moral. So, you take immoral acts and twist them into supposedly moral stories.
Humans are moral because morality is innate. Studies have been done asking atheists vs religious people morality questions (from industrialized countries to tribes that have no religion at all and with little influence by Western society), and consistently morality comes up the same between the two groups.
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
Posts: 3,904
Threads: 213
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
0
Flumper Barflusterbutt Wrote:Personally, the only thing that I think religion does is allow people to attach punishments to not following the moral principles that relgion teaches. It uses the scare tactics of going to hell as a deterent for not abiding.
I agree. But then, that is not morality. Say a person wants to murder someone. But doesn't want to go to jail for 25 years. So, he doesn't murder, not because he is moral, but because he is motivated to avoid punishment.
Insert clever, witty and amusing signature here.
(This post was last modified: 02-18-2009, 02:02 AM by
Banana.)