08-31-2004, 10:30 PM
Quote:Originally posted by banana@Aug 31 2004, 11:25 AM
In reality, yes. But, theoretically, I'd like them to have the same pain inflicted upon them as they inflicted upon others. I think it would be a bigger deterrent than institutionalization. But, since we are not barbaric people, I understand why this should/would never occur.
[snapback]67569[/snapback]
You think torture would be a greater detterent? I don't. I think that a swift (no appeals, no waiting ten years on death row) death for people convicted of cases where there is incontrovertible evidence of the crime would be more of a deterrent. No hanging out on death row. You go from court, to a cell, to the chair within a matter of days. I think that would actually be more of a deterrent.
Now, the problem. and the argument I left myself open to is: what defines "incontrovertible" and what do you do for the cases where there isn't incontrovertible evidence?
I dunno yet :S
