Thread Rating:
  • 3 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Harmon's QB rankings: Brady's second
#1

Rk Player TM Comment
1 Peyton Manning IND Didn't need pinball numbers last year. Could rise again w/o James
2 Tom Brady NE 26 or more TDs in three of his last 4 seasons. Led NFL in yardage
3 Matt Hasselbeck SEA Strong '05 and the addition of Burleson moves him into second level
4 Donovan McNabb PHI Brilliant before the surgery. What does loss of TO mean to his Nos.?
5 Carson Palmer CIN Made the huge leap in 2005 w/ 32 TD. Only 5th due to injury concern
6 Daunte Culpepper MIA Toss the 2005 misery aside. Joins new system w/ great options
7 Mark Bulger STL Top producer when he's on the field. Ill-fated tackle ruined great half
8 Trent Green KAN Health of O-Line crippled '05 season. Still 3rd straight 4,000 yards
9 Jake Delhomme CAR Smith dominant. Add Keyshawn and healthy Drew Carter. Big upside
10 Kurt Warner ARI Had the receivers, now gets a top-tier back. Just needs protection
11 Drew Bledsoe DAL Looked great in spurts, now you add TO. Like Warner, huge if upright
12 Jake Plummer DEN Improved efficiency last year, but TDs down. Still needs WR help
13 Ben Roethlisberger PIT Whisenhunt returns and might feature Ben's right arm w/ loss of Bus
14 Eli Manning NYG Still makes some dangerous tosses, but shut out only once last year
15 Drew Brees NO Some concern as to how quickly he'll recover, but weapons available
16 Aaron Brooks OAK Has the weapons in Moss and Porter. Can he rediscover accuracy?
17 Michael Vick ATL Love the athleticism, but can't rely on TDs on the ground
18 Mark Brunell WAS Topped 3K yards & racked up career-high 23 TDs despite 5 shutouts
19 Byron Leftwich JAC 5 multi-TD efforts in 10 games, but can't stay healthy
20 Jon Kitna DET 26 TD, 3,500 in last starting gig. Has weapons if he wins job
21 David Carr HOU Moulds complements Andre Johnson. Add Bush & Carr on the rise
22 Brad Johnson MIN Hit or miss in '05 after starting. 5 multi-TD games and 4 shutouts
23 Brett Favre GNB Decisions led to 36 TOs. Issue w/ GB management grown tiresome
24 Steve McNair TEN Booted out of team facilities, looks like he'll be moving. Baltimore?
25 Brian Griese CHI Three multi-TD games before lost to injury. He'll battle Grossman
26 Chris Simms TAM Finished strong w/ consecutive 2-TD games
27 Philip Rivers SD Finally starts. L.T., McCardell, and Gates help growing pains
28 Chad Pennington NYJ Two straight early exits send his stock south
29 Kyle Boller BAL Three 3-TD games in the 2nd half. Battle w/ McNair or Collins lurking
30 Kelly Holcomb BUF Losman has fallen out of favor & allegedly being shopped
31 Charlie Frye CLE Appears to have inside track to start over Dilfer entering camp
32 Josh McCown DET Starts behind Kitna on depth chart. Lots of weapons for a big arm
33 Billy Volek TEN Stock up w/ McNair development. Battle from rookie on tap
34 Alex Smith SF Threw 1 TD vs. 11 INT as a rookie. Rebuilding continues by the Bay
35 Kerry Collins FA Still w/o a home for the moment. CIN and BAL most likely suitors
36 Patrick Ramsey NYJ Opportunity to start several games likely behind Pennington
37 Joey Harrington DET Ranks highly based on impending deal to CIN or MIA
38 Rex Grossman CHI Grossman injury history prompted signing of Griese. Battle to come
39 Gus Frerotte STL Martz's gone, but Bulger, Bruce and Holt remain. Threw 18 TD for Fins
40 Jeff Garcia PHI Vet leaves Detroit debacle for Andy Reid's precision offense. Good fit
41 David Garrard JAC Good arm and legs and likely to see some field time behind Leftwich
42 Tony Romo DAL Parcells likes him and he's got great set of receiving options
43 Matt Cassel NE Showed big arm during the season finale against Miami
44 Matt Schaub ATL Heavy trade interest b/c of big arm, would take huge deal to move
45 Matt Leinart TBD Likely the first QB taken and might play if he's in NO or TEN
46 Jim Sorgi IND Averaged 222 yards per game in 2 starts with 3 TD against 1 INT
47 Aaron Rodgers GNB Didn't show much in spot duty last year. GB offense still in flux
48 Vince Young TBD All-world talent, but will that translate to NFL? Vick comparisons apt
49 Sage Rosenfels HOU Hits on Carr continue to pile. Adding Moulds to allow more balance
50 A.J. Feeley SD Capable backup if Rivers scuffles early
51 J.P. Losman BUF Appears to be the odd man out in BUF. Might be dealt on draft day
52 Stefan LeFors CAR Great WR corps w/ addition of Keyshawn. Will need to oust Weinke
53 Tim Rattay TAM Didn't win in '04 as 49er, but was useful in fantasy for several weeks
54 Jay Cutler TBD Smart QB with big arm. Aggressiveness could lead to negative plays
55 Trent Dilfer CLE Enters camp in battle w/ Frye. Just 2 multi-TD games in 11 starts
56 Ken Dorsey SF Despite bad W/L record, was useful in fantasy two years ago
57 Jason Campbell WAS The future at QB in WAS, he'll have speedy wideouts at his disposal
58 Craig Nall BUF Competition for the BUF job appears to include the former GB backup
59 Seneca Wallace SEA Upgraded wideout corps and sweet feet make him a threat
60 Charlie Batch PIT Played well in spots during Roethlisberger absence
61 Mike McMahon MIN Back in NFC Central. The cupboard is bare for the moment
62 Rohan Davey ARI Big arm, but slow release limits upside. Still, with those WRs ...
63 Bradlee Van Pelt DEN Running game rules, but Broncos likely to upgrade WR in draft
64 Damon Huard KAN No. 2 by default now. Changes in a hurry if Martin or Harrington enter
65 Todd Bouman NO Brees' shoulder leaves door open for competition and possible reps
66 Tim Hasselbeck NYG NYG may still make a move for backup. Hasselbeck serviceable
67 Ryan Fitzpatrick STL Fantasy darling for a short spell in '05. Back in the 3rd role for '06
68 Luke McCown TAM He and Rattay battle for 2nd behind Simms
69 Kyle Orton CHI Managed game well to lead Bears to playoffs. Offered zero to fantasy
70 Dan Orlovsky DET The list ends in DET with strong complement of receivers
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
Last Post by WoolyGoat
09-02-2009, 09:55 PM
Last Post by Blondie
02-22-2009, 08:37 PM
Last Post by niko
09-19-2008, 07:14 AM
Last Post by ntype
07-21-2008, 05:39 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)