02-10-2009, 02:22 AM
Cucumber Wrote:No, for a couple of reasons:
My infant son has no risk of any of those things. Like I said before, if he feels that cutting off his foreskin is his best defense against HPV or HIV, he's free to do so as an independent adult.
The study says "may" cut the risk, not will cut the risk. (pun intentional)
African Americans and Hispanics are most at risk for HIV. My son(?) will be neither.
One study is not nearly enough to change the perspective that the medical risks outweigh the benefits. This is not true for me personally, nor is it impacting the medical community. There are hundreds of studies claiming harm. This one doesn't change those things.
The John Hopkins study tested only AA men.
Plus
The study's only conclusion was
Well we all werent born with that luxury.
You have to admit this Johns Hopkins study along with others points to the fact that there is most likely a medical advantage to having a circumcision unless you believe african americans have an extra bone in their penis or something that makes them so different.I don't see any studies posted by you showing how not getting circumcised helps prevent AIDS.Mutilation is obviously a major consideration to think about but the odds are low of that occuring.A lot of your argument is superficial based on very very weird men who are so upset by their circumcision they post on forums about it.
I can sum up my whole philosophy like this.The kid will never miss it and it helps prevent diseases.
See You In Toledo

