Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Overdone Movie Cliche
#1

A lot of movies (don't make me list them :angrySmile have explored the theme of a person who, in order to track a killer must expose themselves to the world/mind of the killer and in doing so they either are, a) changed forever in a fundamental and not necessarily positive way or B) become entangled and have trouble not falling prey to the darkness themselves.

Do you think there is any validity to this cliche?




EDIT: I think by definition cliches must be overused, so arguably my title is redundant, but that's another thread. Fuckers :angry:
Reply
#2

Very little validity. It's not necessary, nor helpful. If you don't know enough about the mind of a killer going in, you're not going to magically figure it out by placing yourself in their shoes. The ability to figure out a killer exists in the mind, not in the soul.
Reply
#3

Did you see the movie 8mm?

Isn't this cliche just an extension of the "exposure to violence makes people violent" theory? So do you think that is bunk as well?
Reply
#4

Quote:Originally posted by leucetios@Sep 10 2004, 11:37 AM
Did you see the movie 8mm?

Isn't this cliche just an extension of the "exposure to violence makes people violent" theory?  So do you think that is bunk as well?
[snapback]72106[/snapback]
Weird......I was just thinking about movies that disturbed me....8mm is right up there. Exposure to violence does not make you violent. There may be a correlation, but it's not a direct relationship. If you did a study on serial killers, and discovered that many of them ate Shreddies as a kid, you couldn't then argue that Shreddies turns people into serial killers. Exposure to violence plays a role for sure, but there are other factors. I hate that cliche. It's assumes people have little mind control over themselves and are simply reactive to what they see/experience.
Reply
#5

Quote:Originally posted by banana@Sep 10 2004, 09:44 AM
Weird......I was just thinking about movies that disturbed me....8mm is right up there.  Exposure to violence does not make you violent.  There may be a correlation, but it's not a direct relationship.  If you did a study on serial killers, and discovered that many of them ate Shreddies as a kid, you couldn't then argue that Shreddies turns people into serial killers.  Exposure to violence plays a role for sure, but there are other factors.  I hate that cliche. It's assumes people have little mind control over themselves and are simply reactive to what they see/experience.
[snapback]72112[/snapback]

Except that Shreddies have no relationship to violence, so that would be illogical. If everyone who hate wheat was forced to eat Shreddies as a kid you could start looking into it. However we're comparing violence (exposure to it either as a kid, or in later years) to violence (acts committe by the person themselves).

I'm not suggesting it is a one to one, given. But at the same time you have to wonder whether that kind of exposure makes people a little less empathetic. The way feminists say pornography objectifies women (a different argument I know) is it possible that violence objectifies humans, and that a prolonged exposure to it could find a person thinking of people less as people and losing some empathy of the individual?

My wife, when they did the holocaust in high school, had to be excused from the class because the images and content bohered he so much. She sees those things and thinks of them as individual people. Her classmates could sit through it with no problem, lacking the empathy for the individual she had. Not to say they are all killers, or were exposed to violence, but it does highlight some of the shades of human empathy.

So now. If you take those people and expose them to more violence. I mean inundate them. Isn't it possible that they lose more empathy and tend more easily towards violence?

too long :roll:
Reply
#6

Pealse(sp?) don't challenge my deficient attention span by posting this type of stuff ever again. TIA.
Reply
#7

^^ x 2
Yes, I agree. And it's the reason why war vets need so much counselling. There comes a point where most human beings can objectify violence and step away from the emotional side of it. It's where that line is that makes the difference. The ones who turn "bad" had a fine line to begin with, a pre-disposition, if you will. Human beings are born with the ability to be violent. They are also born with judgement skills. Switching gears.... :S If I recall correctly, studies on the brains of "psychopaths" have a certain enlarged area in the frontal lobe. It's the area that affects judgement. There is some debate as to whether they are biologically wired to be deviant. If that were true, we could arguably "forgive" all deviants. It's not their fault, right? But, there is more to it than that. Humans are social, not just biological creatures. So, my point - yes, violence can breed violence, but there has to be a biological component, or at least a pre-existing socially devaint component.
Reply
#8

ok. I'm done
Reply
#9

I, for one, enjoyed this thread!

Actual conversation, rather than inane rambling's.

God bless both of you!



:praise: :praise: :praise: :praise:

[size=1][size=2]You're just jealous cause the voices only speak to me.


Son's of Cunniligus - personal trainer.

I speak in tongues.[/size]
[/size]
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
Last Post by Anhil8tor
07-13-2020, 05:43 PM
Last Post by spunky
03-03-2010, 07:45 AM
Last Post by Blondie
02-11-2010, 06:56 PM
Last Post by Vitamin E
12-17-2008, 04:46 PM
Last Post by ntype
05-15-2008, 10:35 AM
Last Post by ntype
02-20-2008, 01:02 AM
Last Post by leeman
08-07-2007, 02:23 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)