InsaneTrain Forums
Since we're talking about suicide... - Printable Version

+- InsaneTrain Forums (https://insanetrain.com)
+-- Forum: General (https://insanetrain.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: General Forum (https://insanetrain.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Thread: Since we're talking about suicide... (/showthread.php?tid=8982)

Pages: 1 2


Since we're talking about suicide... - leucetios - 08-06-2004

Serious question for the group: I am reading a book now about a guy (an inventory) with epilepsy. He is also a creative genius (165 IQ). Epilepsy gets worse when he is thinking hard and being creative. He was about to undergo a surgery that would remove the part of the brain responsible for his seizures. The catch: the surgery would also remove the memory of any person he had an emotional connection with. Wife, kid, girlfriend, friends, he would not be able to remember.

This means, his intellect would be intact, but he would given a clean emotional slate to start over with. No guilt about past experiences. No sense of obligations to people. Nothing.

So. Should he do it? Is he a coward for turning his back on his family? Do they have a right to be angry?


Since we're talking about suicide... - ClayRock - 08-06-2004

my theory is this. if you are a man, and you have a family, that is your responsibilty until the day you die.


Since we're talking about suicide... - Suicide Jim - 08-06-2004

why doesn't he make a viedo recording of all the people he cares about and him tellling him self all of his former emotional memories?


Since we're talking about suicide... - MarkyGman - 08-06-2004

I'd say go for it...yes he has a family, but the rest of the family will still treat him like he is part of the family...and eventually he will get adjusted to his family. Maybe the love won't be as deep at first...but it will grow, especially if they care for him enough, his brain will begin to care back.


Since we're talking about suicide... - Banana - 08-06-2004

Absolutely not. Memories, emotions, that's all we have. It means WAYYY more than intellect. IMHO.


Since we're talking about suicide... - MarkyGman - 08-06-2004

Quote:Originally posted by Suicide Jim@Aug 6 2004, 02:38 PM
why doesn't he make a viedo recording of all the people he cares about and him tellling him self all of his former emotional memories?
you just watched "50 first dates" didn't you? Big Grin


Since we're talking about suicide... - Suicide Jim - 08-06-2004

it was some where in my mind but it is a some what logical thing to do.


Since we're talking about suicide... - leucetios - 08-06-2004

He could make a video or write a novel about how he feels. BUT. You have to realize, the years that make those connections are gone. If his kid is a little punk, he loves him anyway cause it is his kid. He could tell himself, you love this person. But after the surgery that connection is gone. If the kid is a brat, he's just going to think "brat" and not feel the obligation.

He won't have to place nice with anyone anymore.


Since we're talking about suicide... - Suicide Jim - 08-06-2004

i personaly wouldn't mind forgeting it all. it would make life a bit easyer.


Since we're talking about suicide... - leucetios - 08-06-2004

and so if you had an excuse like fixing a major (but non fatal) disease would you? Despite the whole leaving your family feeling abandoned?


Since we're talking about suicide... - Suicide Jim - 08-06-2004

i hate to admit it, but there is a part of me that's so cold i wouldn't care. i'd start again from nothing. no love, no pain, no scars of life.


Since we're talking about suicide... - fem - 08-06-2004

This is a very hard decision, I will have to think about it. Nice post Leu. Smile


Since we're talking about suicide... - Beaucephus - 08-06-2004

I don't think he should do it. Right now his wife has no idea how good she has it. Every time he takes a bath she can just throw in some laundry with him and kill two birds with one stone.


Since we're talking about suicide... - ClayRock - 08-06-2004

beau...thats fucking hilarious!!! :loool:


Since we're talking about suicide... - Banana - 08-06-2004

This reminds me of a question.

If you were to get...let's say $2 million dollars, and you could do anythign you wanted with it in one week, you'd jump at the chance, right? What about if all memory of what you did in that week was erased? You would never remember. Would you still do it? I wouldn't. It wouldn't be worth it. But, that's just me.


Since we're talking about suicide... - ClayRock - 08-06-2004

couldn't you write yourself a note that says you put it into a swiss bank, then you could just recover it after the week is up?


Since we're talking about suicide... - Suicide Jim - 08-06-2004

i would. i'd put half in the bank, then i'd buy a shit load of cool stuff and leave a recept where i could easily find it.


Since we're talking about suicide... - leucetios - 08-06-2004

I'd do it. But I wouldn't use the money for trips or anything. After a trip all you have is the memory. I'd buy cool shit. In a week I won't remember shopping for it, but I'd still have the cool shit? Big loss


Since we're talking about suicide... - Banana - 08-06-2004

Ok, you guys....this isn't a "Choose Your Adventure" scenario. Let me clarify...you have a week to spend the money...after that, you have no money, no things, no memory of any of it.


Since we're talking about suicide... - leucetios - 08-06-2004

no things?!?!?! fuck it. Why bother