InsaneTrain Forums
Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Printable Version

+- InsaneTrain Forums (https://insanetrain.com)
+-- Forum: General (https://insanetrain.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: General Forum (https://insanetrain.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Thread: Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players (/showthread.php?tid=37262)

Pages: 1 2


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Anhil8tor - 06-20-2006

#1 in my book is Barry Sanders. Dude was a great runner.. but he was an alright football player. Don't bitch and moan about how great his runs were... We all know he had quite a few of those..

How many did he have for -3 or -5? If it was 3rd and 2.. could barry go straight ahead and gain 3? Nope... he'd run to the left... reverse field.. goto the right... stop.. start.. and sometimes he'd get it.. sometimes he wouldn't.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Raiden - 06-20-2006

Ben Roethlesberger

also, Zack Crockett > Barry Sanders @ 3rd & 2.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - lookout below - 06-20-2006

Deion Sanders. Dude is a primadonna that can't tackle.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - SanDog - 06-20-2006

Anhil8tor Wrote:#1 in my book is Barry Sanders. Dude was a great runner.. but he was an alright football player. Don't bitch and moan about how great his runs were... We all know he had quite a few of those..

How many did he have for -3 or -5? If it was 3rd and 2.. could barry go straight ahead and gain 3? Nope... he'd run to the left... reverse field.. goto the right... stop.. start.. and sometimes he'd get it.. sometimes he wouldn't.

With the o-line detroit had, he had no option but to go east west. Dude was top notch. Had he remained in the game, he would have killed Emmit Smith's record.

Over rated? Peyton Manning. I am pretty sure any decent QB could do what he has done given that protection and those tools. The fact that he has not been able to lead his team to the promise land speaks volumes. Caves under pressure.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Tribal Dragon - 06-20-2006

Anhil8tor Wrote:#1 in my book is Barry Sanders. Dude was a great runner.. but he was an alright football player. Don't bitch and moan about how great his runs were... We all know he had quite a few of those..

How many did he have for -3 or -5? If it was 3rd and 2.. could barry go straight ahead and gain 3? Nope... he'd run to the left... reverse field.. goto the right... stop.. start.. and sometimes he'd get it.. sometimes he wouldn't.
His offensive line sucked. Put him behind the wall that Emmit Smith had, and watch how many 2000 yard seasons he would of had.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - WoolyGoat - 06-20-2006

8 is one of the greatest plagiarists this site has ever known.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Raiden - 06-20-2006

WoolyGoat Wrote:MP is one of the greatest plagiarists this site has ever known.

:*>


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Paddy - 06-20-2006

David Beckham


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Raiden - 06-20-2006

Paddy Wrote:David Beckham

sometimes you make me chuckle.

can I buy you a drink?


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - SanDog - 06-20-2006

Tribal Dragon Wrote:His offensive line sucked. Put him behind the wall that Emmit Smith had, and watch how many 2000 yard seasons he would of had.

Very original.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Anhil8tor - 06-20-2006

WoolyGoat Wrote:8 is one of the greatest plagiarists this site has ever known.


link?
That is off the top of my head.

I don't buy the offensive line crap.. there have been some great running backs that have played with piss poor lines. Sanders was a great athlete.. he was not a great running back. I stand by that.. I watched him many times...

Didn't barry sanders once have a game with 25 rushes for -1 yards?


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Tribal Dragon - 06-20-2006

SanDog Wrote:Very original.
I didn't see your post until after I had posted mine.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - SanDog - 06-20-2006

Tribal Dragon Wrote:I didn't see your post until after I had posted mine.

I figured that our you were getting ready to apply to the New York Times.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - TomFoolery - 06-20-2006

Anhil8tor Wrote:Didn't barry sanders once have a game with 25 rushes for -1 yards?

Yeah, and he also had 14 straight 100 yard games. And a 2,000 yard season. And 10 straight Pro Bowls. And over 15,000 career rushing yards. And a Heisman Trophy. And a Rookie of the Year award. And an MVP award.

But he's not good.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Anhil8tor - 06-20-2006

TomFoolery Wrote:Yeah, and he also had 14 straight 100 yard games. And a 2,000 yard season. And 10 straight Pro Bowls. And over 15,000 career rushing yards. And a Heisman Trophy. And a Rookie of the Year award. And an MVP award.

But he's not good.


It is my opinion. Some can say the same thing about Montana, Rice, Emmit Smith, Walter Payton..

Fuck me for trying to get the board moving. I don't buy into that run around bullshit..

if you are a barry sander fan than you have to be a Micheal Vick fan.. same shit different position.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Flumper Barflusterbutt - 06-20-2006

Anhil8tor Wrote:It is my opinion. Some can say the same thing about Montana, Rice, Emmit Smith, Walter Payton..

Fuck me for trying to get the board moving. I don't buy into that run around bullshit..

if you are a barry sander fan than you have to be a Micheal Vick fan.. same shit different position.

Um, Barry Sanders = running back = running around

Michael Vick = Quarterback = not so much running around.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Anhil8tor - 06-21-2006

I'll throw favre in the mix too. He is a future hall of famer.. but the cheeseheads have made this guy into a god..

Granted.. he has won a title.. but how many has he lost. Anyone remember the interception against the eagles in the playoffs? Fucker just threw the ball in the air..

His biggest accomplishment is most touchdowns in a season (39) which is behind marino and warner..

and most touchdowns in a career behind marino and tarkenton


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - minorthreat - 06-21-2006

Manning? Favre? Overrated? No way.


Michael Vick is. Randy Moss is. Deion Sanders is.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - BIRD33 - 06-21-2006

Favre overrated yes.Manning a little.


Who in your opinion is some of the most over-rated football players - Anhil8tor - 06-21-2006

I was speaking strictly about hall of famers..

Don't get me wrong.. a hall of famer is a great player.. but don't tell me that some of them aren't overrated...

Someone like TF loves everything Barry Sanders did and he dosen't remember the bad games... the piss poor attitude.. all of the excess