Moral question -
greg - 11-02-2004
I know 2 teenage girls(13, 15) who's mother ran out on them, and their father years ago. Recently she started coming back around and getting somewhat involved in their lives again.
She apparently was trying to kick a meth habit and had good and bad days. We got a call the other day notifying us that the night before she took her life.
Question;
Does anyone have the right to end their life as they see fit, or do the people around them that they hurt take precident?
Thoughts?
Moral question - Banana - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by greg@Nov 1 2004, 04:14 PM
I know 2 teenage girls(13, 15) who's mother ran out on them, and their father years ago. Recently she started coming back around and getting somewhat involved in their lives again.
She apparently was trying to kick a meth habit and had good and bad days. We got a call the other day notifying us that the night before she took her life.
Question;
Does anyone have the right to end their life as they see fit, or do the people around them that they hurt take precident?
Thoughts?
[snapback]94330[/snapback]
Hmmm. Ummmm. If they are hurting, and you have no way of knowing how much, they own their destiny. Suicide is a selfish act - but, since we can never be inside the minds of those who take their lives, it is not our place to judge. She had kids, she hurt them, but who is to say that her continued presence (i.e., living) would have harmed tham more than her death.
My mother took her own life, and while it hurt me and my sister, we learned to cope with it. My mother is finally free of pain. I can't fault her for that.
Just my humble opinion.
Moral question -
snarg - 11-02-2004
my wife died in my arms
while technically it was not suicide, we both know better
i am not sayin it was right or wrong
but i wish she had not left us

narg:
Moral question - Beaucephus - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by snarg@Nov 1 2004, 05:36 PM
my wife died in my arms
while technically it was not suicide, we both know better
i am not sayin it was right or wrong
but i wish she had not left us
narg:
[snapback]94350[/snapback]
Holy shit. That's harsh. I don't know how I would have handle a situation that warranted something like that. :|
Moral question -
Velvet - 11-02-2004
When someone is dying of cancer I think they should be able to take there life with those they love around them . To take it by suicide because your unhappy to me is selfish . People never think of the ones who are left behind that wonder what if .... Greg the girls are the ones who need all the support and understanding now . Even though the woman wasn't involved to much in their lives she was still there Mum .
Moral question -
snarg - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by Beaucephus@Nov 1 2004, 05:39 PM
Holy shit. That's harsh. I don't know how I would have handle a situation that warranted something like that. :|
[snapback]94355[/snapback]
you wouldn't be able to handle it

narg:
Moral question - Banana - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by Velvet@Nov 1 2004, 04:48 PM
When someone is dying of cancer I think they should be able to take there life with those they love around them . To take it by suicide because your unhappy to me is selfish . [snapback]94363[/snapback]
Who is to say that suffering from cancer is any more painful than suffering from depression?
Moral question -
greg - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by snarg@Nov 1 2004, 05:36 PM
my wife died in my arms
while technically it was not suicide, we both know better
i am not sayin it was right or wrong
but i wish she had not left us
narg:
[snapback]94350[/snapback]
I'm torn on this subject.
I think that if life is no longer worth living (opinion of the suicidal party) then why go on?
But yet, I've been down and felt like there is no future, but the will to live kicked in and I pulled my head out of my ass (personal opinion) and kept on keeping on.
Just sayin.
Moral question - Banana - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by greg@Nov 1 2004, 04:51 PM
But yet, I've been down and felt like there is no future, but the will to live kicked in and I pulled my head out of my ass (personal opinion) and kept on keeping on.
Just sayin.
[snapback]94368[/snapback]
Yes, greg, but for people who are mentally ill, they have trouble with the "keep going" part. Depression is an illness, just like cancer. Most people just don't recognize it as such.
Moral question - MarkyGman - 11-02-2004
Quote:Originally posted by greg@Nov 1 2004, 06:51 PM
I'm torn on this subject.
I think that if life is no longer worth living (opinion of the suicidal party) then why go on?
But yet, I've been down and felt like there is no future, but the will to live kicked in and I pulled my head out of my ass (personal opinion) and kept on keeping on.
Just sayin.
[snapback]94368[/snapback]
Other thing is some people feel their life is no longer worth living for periods of time , then life takes a nice turn and you could be back to enjoying life. Suicide in a lot of cases ends a life that was far from over and definantly was worth living.
On the other hand if your suffering and you've lost all hope, you've pretty much ended it allready.
Moral question -
Charon - 11-02-2004
Far as the Mom waiting til her kids were older good for her at least she raised them. Cancer, my Son's g-mother just died after a year bout, if she would have seeked out a better Dr. she might have beat it. Some lady just beat level 4 cervical at my wife's hosp. due to a good Dr. and radical treatment. So you tell me do you fight or just run off to um Canada, I mean the wilderness to die like the natives did ? Taking ones life is weak at least do it in a car wreck so the family can get insurance.
Moral question -
greg - 11-03-2004
Quote:Originally posted by Charon@Nov 2 2004, 10:02 AM
Far as the Mom waiting til her kids were older good for her at least she raised them. Cancer, my Son's g-mother just died after a year bout, if she would have seeked out a better Dr. she might have beat it. Some lady just beat level 4 cervical at my wife's hosp. due to a good Dr. and radical treatment. So you tell me do you fight or just run off to um Canada, I mean the wilderness to die like the natives did ? Taking ones life is weak at least do it in a car wreck so the family can get insurance.
[snapback]94458[/snapback]
A little harsh in the wording, however, I understand the sentiment.